Shop ‘Summer House’s’ Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke’s Amazon Holiday Gifts

Summer House stars Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke know a good thing when they see one — even if it doesn’t have to do with a Hamptons vacation.

I chatted with the couple at Amazon’s Home for the Holidays event this month, where they walked me through their top gift picks and recommendations from the site’s holiday shop. Batula rounded up stunning beauty and fashion finds — including a pair of comfortable boots that she tells PEOPLE, “looks designer but is not a designer price” — while Cooke highlighted coveted tech and men’s styles. The pair also picked out stellar gifts fit for folks of all ages, including snuggly slippers and games from just $20.

Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke’s Amazon Holiday Gift Picks

• Nostalgic Holiday Find: Fujifilm Instax Mini 12 Instant Camera, $84 (orig. $94)
• Gift for “Everyone”: Brightland The Artist Capsule Infused Olive Oils, $120 (orig. $150)
• Amanda’s Beauty Favorite: Sol de Janeiro Party of Two Beauty Gift Set, $25
• Kyle’s Secret Obsession: Lego Technic Ferrari Model Car Building Set, $230
• 30K Just Bought: Owala FreeSip Insulated Stainless Steel Water Bottle, $30
• “Looks Designer”: Schutz Maryana Slouch Boots, $238
• White Elephant Gift Pick: Guess The Gibberish Card Game, $20
• Celeb Brand: Martha Stewart 16-Piece Lockton Knife Set with Block, $85
• Cozy Winter Staple: Ugg Tazz II Slipper, $145
• Designer Deal: Marc Jacobs The Glam Mirror Shoulder Bag, $177 (orig. $295)

Fujifilm Instax Mini 12 Instant Camera

The holiday season is the time to make memories with your loved ones, and Batula and Cooke know just how to capture them. This Fujifilm camera captures memories in an instant and prints out high-quality photos on the spot. “I just think it’s a good little throwback, and I feel like everybody should have one for those special occasions,” Cooke tells PEOPLE. “It’s the instant gratification and the nostalgia of having to take one photo and hope it’s good.”

Brightland The Artist Capsule Infused Olive Oils

Batula and Cooke have also cracked the code on a luxe yet practical gift fit for just about anyone. “When you’re really struggling to find a gift, almost everybody, whether they cook or not, could use some olive oil,” Cooke explains. “There’s a lot of bad olive oil out there — Brightland is a nice gift… You can literally taste the difference. We have to use it sparingly.”

This bundle includes four types of infused olive oil that are great for cooking, dressing, and dipping. There’s Rosette (garlic), Ardor (chili), Lucid (lemon), and Arise (basil). “My mom got it for us last year for Christmas from Amazon… Now we’re going to gift it to everyone,” Batula enthuses.

Sol de Janeiro Party of Two Beauty Gift Set

As far as stocking stuffers and affordable holiday gifts go, Batula raves about Sol de Janeiro’s ever-popular fragrances. “The smell is so good, you can’t go wrong with it,” she shares. 

The brand’s Spritz and Shine fragrance set is currently sold out on Amazon, but this duo is available in Sol de Janeiro’s most popular scents, including Cheirosa 62 and Cheirosa 68. Each bundle comes with a body mist and matching body cream that any sweet gourmand fragrance-lover would enjoy.

Lego Technic Ferrari Model Car Building Set

Cooke convinced me that Lego sets might just be the perfect gift for all ages. “It gets your kids off of screens to do something that is certainly a little more stimulating and tangible,” he explains. Batula agreed: “It’s a really fun thing to do together as a couple or as a family.”

Cooke’s pick of the season could be a top choice for the man in your life. This 1,361-piece set creates an F1 model car (the Ferrari SF-24) that provides hours of fun and turns into decor when it’s built. “I literally wrote my college essay about Legos,” Cooke tells PEOPLE. “That’s just proof that men never grow up,” Batula jokes.

The holiday season is in full swing, and Summer House’s Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke both curated great gift guides with easy-to-shop finds at Amazon. Snag their picks to ace your upcoming gift exchange. 

Owala FreeSip Insulated Stainless Steel Water Bottle

Schutz Maryana Slouch Boots

Guess The Gibberish Card Game

Martha Stewart 16-Piece Lockton Knife Set with Block

Ugg Tazz II Slipper

Marc Jacobs The Glam Mirror Shoulder Bag

PS by Paul Smith T-Shirt 3-Pack

Eberjey Gisele Relaxed Short Pajama Set

Cole Haan Grandpro Luxe Slip-On Sneakers

De’Longhi Dedica Duo Compact Espresso and Coffee Maker

Shark CryoGlow LED Face Mask, $273 with coupon