Andy Cohen Drops Kid Baker’s Holiday Creation in Live ‘Today’ Moment

Kitchen blunder! 

Andy Cohen got a little too excited on Monday, Nov. 24, while co-hosting Today with Jenna & Friends. When the Bravo host, 57, participated in a segment highlighting kid holiday bakers, he accidentally dropped several handmade cupcakes live on the air. 

The moment happened when Cohen was trying to show off a tray of intricately decorated cupcakes featuring fondant holiday-themed creations on the top, courtesy of 14-year-old Finlay from Virginia. 

“Oh my God, look! Yum, y’all,” Cohen exclaimed, tilting the wooden display board up to get a better camera angle. But as he tried to show off the treats, multiple cupcakes slid down off the board, plopping onto the table. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

There was an audible groan from the show’s producers as Cohen rushed to pick up the delicacies. 

“Oh, shoot! Sorry,” he exclaimed as the kid baker laughed off the moment. “I’m sorry, I was trying to show off the…”

Co-host Jenna Bush Hager chuckled, adding, “He was too excited!” 

He later told the bakers how “impressed” he was, noting, “You all have mad skills.” 

He also said of his son Benjamin, 6, and daughter Lucy, 3, “I want a kid baker! My kids do nothing.” 

As a reward for being a part of the segment, the show give all three kid bakers an apron, holiday cookie cutters and a $250 gift card to Williams & Sonoma. 

The awkward on-air moment came after Cohen recently called out Bush Hager during a recent segment on Watch What Happens Live. 

Cohen said he’d had his own show segments stolen, saying, “We get games stolen all the time, and we say nothing,” before adding, “Prompter wars, I’m looking at you, Jenna Bush.”

Neither Bush Hager nor Cohen addressed the comment during Monday’s show. Cohen is expected to co-host Today with Jenna & Friends all week.